Why Secondhand Toys Make the Best Holiday Gifts This Year

Why Secondhand Toys Make the Best Holiday Gifts This Year

For many parents, holidays mean lists, shopping within budgets, and the pressure to find the perfect gift. This year, between growing concern for sustainability and the high cost of living, families are choosing secondhand and open-box toys as gifts. 

Giving second-hand or off-price gifts doesn’t mean you are giving less. Instead, it means gifting better: for your wallet, for the recipient, and for the planet. 

Pre-Loved Doesn’t Mean A Lesser Gift

People still hesitate to give secondhand toys as gifts during the holidays because of the belief that pre-loved means lower quality. That’s understandable, since "used" is by nature not "shiny and new." But the truth is that pre-loved toys can deliver the same, and sometimes more joy, than new ones. 

More important than a condition label is the actual quality of a pre-owned toy. Shops like Toycycle thoroughly check, clean, and curate open-box and pre-loved toys that look and function like new. 

PlanToys wooden push walker for babies and early toddlers

PlanToys Baby Walker Open Box

At Toycycle, selecting used toys for the holidays means you are giving more than just a toy. It's a toy that’s packed with sustainability, creativity, and care.

Kids rarely observe whether you are gifting a new toy from a store or one from a planet-friendly source. The only thing they see is the fun it promises during play. 

Plus, heirloom quality toys from high-end brands like PlanToys, Janod, and Lovevery, are built to last. You can trust you're getting a product that will hold up to ongoing play.

So this holiday season, shop open-box or pre-loved at Toycycle. We promise you won't be compromising on quality or excitement.

waytoplay King of the Road Toys waytoplay Road Sets

Value Meets Sustainability

Holiday spending can pressure budgets, especially during difficult economic times. But cutting costs doesn’t mean you have to cut corners as well. While shopping for secondhand toys as gifts, you are making a smart choice for your budget, and a smart choice for the planet. 

Here is how value and sustainability work together:

  • When you purchase open-box or used toys, you can easily save 30-60% as compared to new retail prices.
  • Every reused toy decreases landfill waste, and saves energy required to create and ship a new one.
  • At Toycycle,  quality control is strict. This means you are getting an excellent condition or even like-new holiday gift for your child, with a smaller carbon footprint.

How Buying Secondhand Benefits The Environment

Buying second-hand reduces carbon emissions because it avoids the need to manufacture a brand-new product—and manufacturing is the most carbon-intensive stage of a product’s life. When you choose a used item:

  • No new raw materials have to be extracted
  • No new factory production is required
  • No new packaging is created

All of that upstream activity produces significant CO₂. Reusing an existing product skips those steps entirely, which keeps its “carbon cost” from happening a second time.

By choosing open-box or second-hand, you shrink waste and the carbon footprint of your gifts for a greener holiday season.

Beatles + Loog Mini Guitar - Anthology Guitars

Loog Mini Acoustic Guitar

Toycycle’s Quality Standards

At Toycycle, every toy passes through a quality inspection ensuring that it's ready for another round of joy.

  • Strict Inspection: Every toy undergoes a full inspection. Our team checks the cosmetics, function, and safety of each item.
  • Sustainable Packaging: We ship every toy in reused or sustainable packaging made from recyclable materials. This means less waste.
  • Cleanliness: All our toys are checked for cleanliness and receive necessary cleaning, from a simple wipe-down to a full wash.
  • Unused Open-Box Toys: Toycycle offers open-box toys as well. These are often products that were purchased and returned without being used. Sometimes, open-box means a perfectly good toy whose packaging was damaged in transit or in the warehouse.

Open-Box Toys Are Ideal for Gifting

Consider open-box gifts as the secret of smart shoppers. These are like-new products whose boxes have been opened but that show no signs of use. Therefore, they can be considered new, just without the original packaging. 

At Toycycle, these open-box toys are among the most popular for the holiday season. Here are a few gift-ready favorites for your list:

  • waytoplay Flexible Road Sets:  “Just as advertised. Came eco-packaged with all pieces in perfect condition!”- Stephanie M.
  • Open Box PlanToys: These wooden toys are made sustainably and built to last generations.
  • Loog Mini Guitar: This mini guitar is an excellent and educational gift for music-loving kids, hitting all the right notes.
  • Playmobil Sets: Kids love Playmobil. And buying used is a steal.

You can be confident that these used and open-box toys will arrive clean, complete, and ready to wrap. 

EKOBO Bamboo & Silicone Sippy Cup 2Pk Baby & Toddler

Overstock EKOBO Sippy Cups

Hear It From Parents Who Switched

Still doubtful about gifting secondhand toys? Hear it from parents who shared their feedback after switching:

The toy was in perfect shape. Honestly, you would never be able to tell whether it was from the store or not. My daughter was thrilled, and I loved that it came in recyclable packaging!” – Andrea L., Ontario

For the first time, I was purchasing used toys for the season, and I’m never going back. Outstanding quality, great prices, and it feels good to shop sustainably.”  – Mark D., California

These reviews show that gifting used toys is a smart choice for budget and eco-conscious parents

Ways to Find the Perfect Secondhand Toy

Toycycle makes shopping for secondhand toys gifts easy. The store organizes toys by brand, age, and play type categories. From infants to tweens, a wide variety is available for all. A few tips:

  • Shop Early: Open-box toys sell fast starting in November
  • Access Discounts: Get on the VIP mailing list for early access to discounts
  • Bundle & Save: Buy multiple toys at once to save on shipping

Shop Open-box and Pre-loved Toys for Every Age

Choosing open-box and second-hand gifts reduces waste and cuts carbon emissions—making your holiday shopping kinder to the planet. 

Plantoys Pull-Along Hedgehog Toys

PlanToys Pull Along Hedgehog

 

Back to blog